Cinema Strikes BackContact

NewsReviewsDVD CalendarContestsFilm FestivalsMoviesPeopleInterviewsLinksAboutContact
New York Asian Film Festival 2008 Report 14: DORORO and SPARROW
Posted on 09.09.08 by Jeff @ 6:15 am

New York Asian Film Festival 2008

Dororo
Country and year: Japan (2007)
Director: Akihiko Shiota
Stars: Satoshi Tsumabuki, Kou Shibasaki
Review by: Jeff
Four stars out of four stars

”Dororo"Dororo features everything one could reasonably hope to find in an action blockbuster: action, suspense, an engaging plot, and mind-bending weirdness. Although I did not take notes during the screening of the film, my recollection of the plot (much of which is told in flashback) is as follows: A warrior seeks to become the dominant ruler of Japan by striking a deal with the dozens of demons who occupy a temple. In exchange for the warrior’s infant son, the demons will grant the warrior military victory. Each of the demons removes a different internal or external organ from the infant, whose mother then sends him in a basket down the river, much like Moses in ancient Egypt. A magical hermit rescues the infant, and grows replacement organs for him. The infant grows up to be a warrior himself (now played by Satoshi Tsumabuki), who is charged with the mission of slaying each of the demons who has stolen his organs, and accompanied by a scrappy female pickpocket who also lacks a name (played by Kou Shibasaki). Every time a demon is defeated, our protagonist recovers one of his original organs, and comes closer to reaching the inevitable confrontation with his evil father. (It gives nothing away to acknowlege this event, which is telegraphed from the beginning of the film.)

As one can tell from the above plot description, Dororo is one loopy movie, albeit one told with a completely straight face. To wit: the organless infant protagonist resembles Dr. Bunsen Honeydew from The Muppet Show. Moreover, many of the demons are also fabulously, imaginatively rendered, in a style that is reminscent of the Yokai Monsters, but updated to reflect the capabilities in scale and fluidity of movement that are offered by CGI. The scenes in which our hero fights the demons are quite thrilling. Although I don’t generally enjoy CGI-heavy action scenes, the fights in Dororo are expertly choreographed by Tony Ching Siu Tung (of A Chinese Ghost Story fame). In a touch obviously inspired by Kill Bill, many of the action scenes are set to music that is alternately reminiscent of the Gipsy Kings and Ennio Morricone. The final confrontation between father and son is also quite rousing and satisfying.

Kill Bill and Yokai Monsters are far from the only films wittily referenced in Dororo. The initial appearance of our protagonist occurs in a rough-and-tumble bar that clearly is meant to invoke the cantina scene in Star Wars. Additionally, one of the best scenes in the film involves our hero’s confrontation with a vampiric demon in female form who resembles the ghosts in classic Japanese horror films such as Kuroneko. Lord of the Rings is another obvious reference point. However, mostly as a result of its unique plot, the film feels like more than the sum of its fun reference points and exciting action scenes. Indeed, the film’s only major deficit is that Kou Shibasaki’s performance mostly consists of overbearing, allegedly “cute” mugging for the camera, but that is probably precisely the performance that the filmmakers wanted. All of the other cast members acquit themselves pretty well. Satoshi Tsumakuki lacks gravitas, but gives a likable enough performance, and does a fine job with the action scenes.

Dororo will be released on Region 1 DVD on September 23, 2008.

Sparrow
Country and year: Hong Kong (2008)
Director: Johnnie To
Stars: Simon Yam, Kelly Lin
Review by: Jeff
Three stars out of four stars

”Sparrow"Sparrow has been hyped by many to be a quasi-musical and as such a major departure for the prolific Johnnie To, who in recent years has brought us such hard-boiled efforts as the Election films and Mad Detective. Indeed, the opening sequence of the film, in which the titular animal files into Simon Yam’s apartment, and he attempts to catch it, is practically balletic. However, following that striking sequence, the film settles into a seriocomic tone that is not that different from that of many other Hong Kong crime films, To’s included. In fact, Sparrow is a modest, lighthearted crime film, albeit one made with the very highest level of craftsmanship.

The film’s threadbare plot tells the story of a tight-knit band of pickpockets, led by Simon Yam. These gents find themselves caught up in a scheme hatched by a femme fatale, played by the lovely Kelly Lin, who is the bored mistress of a very powerful older gent with a shady past. She convinces the pickpockets to help her pull off a major heist of the old man’s treasure, thereby freeing her from his grasp. Of course, things do not go as planned.

As one might except, the main pleasures of Sparrow have little to do with the plot. The film’s chief attraction is a dazzlingly choreographed duel between rival pickpockets that is a masterpiece of editing. Film students undoubtedly will be studying this sequence for years to come. Also of note is the film’s lovingly photographed depiction of Hong Kong. Indeed, many of the film’s best sequences were shot on location in Hong Kong, and the city gives these scenes a real energy. Simon Yam also turns in a typically charismatic performance; the man has truly been on a roll since he broke out of the Category 3 ghetto and started playing major roles in To’s recent films.


Filed under: Movie Reviews and Movie Reviews: Hong Kong and Movie Reviews: Japan and Rating: Good ★★★ and Rating: Great ★★★★ and People: Johnnie To and People: Simon Yam and Contributors: Jeff and Film Festivals: New York Asian Film Festival 2008
Comments:

1 Comment »

  1. I agree with Jeff’s comments, though I would say I enjoyed Sparrow rather more and Dororo rather less. For me, the best thing about Dororo were the creature designs and showdowns - I wish they’d provided more background on the demons and spent less time on Shibasaki’s hijinks. The plot never really grabbed me - I wonder if a tighter sequel (supposedly two are planned) might do better for having gotten the origin story out of the way.

    Sparrow, on the other hand, I enjoyed thoroughly, though I acknowledge that it is no masterpiece. Xavier Jamaux and Fred Avril’s soundtrack in particular (sample it here) won me over immediately. The music and the film have a unique blend of French and HK sensibilities that just clicked for me. I never thought I’d see Johnnie To channel Jacques Demy and Michel Legrand, but I’m glad I did.

    Comment by David — December 1, 2008 @ 2:16 pm


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)



Search

Latest Movie News
* Satoshi Kon, Innovative Anime Director, Dies at 46 (08/25/2010)
* New York Asian Film Festival 2010 Report 7: CSB Interviews Bruce Leung Siu-Leung, Kung Fu Actor Extraordinaire and Star of Gallants (08/23/2010)
* CSB Interviews William Lustig about “William Lustig Presents” at the Anthology Film Archives (08/10/2010)
* Guillermo Del Toro to Scale Mountains of Madness (07/30/2010)
* New York Asian Film Festival 2010 Report 6: CSB Interviews Yu Irie, Director of 8000 Miles (Saitama no Rapper) and 8000 Miles 2: Girl Rappers (07/20/2010)
 

* Shusuke Kaneko
* Malik Bader
* Nobuhiro Yamashita
* Sabu
* Johnnie To
* Edgar Wright, Simon Pegg & Nick Frost
* Bong Joon-Ho
 
Recent Comments
Kid Supreme: Turbo, man i have to credit a lot of my break dance style back in
junskies: i like im saw happy 2 say exciting action drama and survival complete plot storiess
junskies: i new im believe its saw touch im watch the movie is battle royale it
junskies: i wish ilike 2 watch new movie battle royal part 3 and part 4
bunty: nice
Sigg3: Thanks for the tip, now I'm gonna have to look into Sarli :)
David Austin: Stuart Gordon did a decent adaptation of Shadow Over Innsmouth called Dagon almost 10 years
spm: as cool as i think this is, i think something like Shadow over Innsmouth would
george: I had a 6 word line in this thing, "It looks like there's nobody
gerg: hahaha, most unrealistic piece of sh-- I've ever seen, the worst plot, acting, directing etc,

Movie News
Australia
Canada
France
Germany
Hong Kong
India
Israel
Japan
Malaysia
New Zealand
Pakistan
Poland
Singapore
South Korea
Taiwan
Thailand
Uganda
UK
USA
Vietnam

By Type:
DVD News
Movie Quotes
MP3 Podcasts
Obituaries
Production Info
Rumors
Trailer News
Trivia

External Article
External Interview

By Studio:
IFC Films
Milkyway Image
Shaw Brothers
Sony Pictures
Warner Bros.
More Studios >

Movies
2007
Bug
Grind House
Rogue

2006
Adam's Apples
Apocalypto
Casino Royale
Descent, The
Exiled
Funky Forest
Pan's Labyrinth
Scanner Darkly, A
Superman Returns
Sympathy for Lady Vengeance


Latest Reviews
* Decades Later, Argentinian Sex Symbol Isabel Sarli Receives Her First American Retrospective (08/06/2010)
* Japan Cuts 2010 Report 3 (07/13/2010)
* Japan Cuts 2010 Report 2 (07/08/2010)
* New York Asian Film Festival 2010 Report 3/Japan Cuts 2010 Report 1 (06/30/2010)
* New York Asian Film Festival 2010 Report 2 (06/28/2010)

Movie Reviews
By Country:
Australia
Canada
Czech
Europe
Germany
Hong Kong
India
Indonesia
Iran
Italy
Japan
Russia
Spain
South Korea
Sweden
Thailand
Turkey
UK
USA

By Rating:
Great ****
Good ***
Average **
Poor *

By Author:
Charlie
David
Jeff
Pete

By Guest Writer:
Brian
John
Mike G.
Mike M.
Wade

Cable:
Cable Series

External Reviews

People
Argento, Dario
Bale, Christian
Chan-wook, Park
Cheh, Chang
Chow Sing Chi, Stephen
Craig, Daniel
Freeman, Morgan
Giamatti, Paul
Gilliam, Terry
Howard, Ron
Hark, Tsui
Jaa, Tony
Jackson, Peter
Jee-woon, Kim
July, Miranda
Kaige, Chen
Kar-wai, Wong
Kurosawa, Kiyoshi
Kuriyama, Chiaki
Lau, Andy
Miike, Takashi
Miyazaki, Hayao
Myung-se, Lee
Nolan, Christopher
Spielberg, Steven
Suzuki, Seijun
Tarantino, Quentin
To, Johnnie
Tse, Nicholas
Vaughn, Matthew
Yen, Donnie
Yeoh, Michelle
Yimou, Zhang
Ziyi, Zhang
More People >

Archive
  • 2010
  • 2009

  • RSS Syndication

    Add to Google

    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    Add Cinema Strikes Back - Covering the World of Film to Newsburst from CNET News.com

    Add to My AOL

    Add to netvibes

    Subscribe in Bloglines

    Add to The Free Dictionary

    Add to Bitty Browser

    Add to Plusmo

    Subscribe in podnova


    Credits and Copyright
    Proudly powered by WordPress. All content © 2004-2005 Cinema Strikes Back.
    Theme by Theron Parlin